Resale vs New Flat — Which is Better?
You can buy a resale flat from an earlier owner or book in a new project. Costs, paperwork, risk and the loan all differ. This guide compares the two and lists what to check in each.
The basic difference
A resale flat already exists, so you can see it, measure it and meet the neighbours. The seller has owned it for some time, and the building may have a society. A flat in a new project is bought from a developer, often before it is built, and the Real Estate Act then governs your booking. The first option offers certainty about what you get. The second offers newer fittings and the Act's protections. Your budget, timeline and risk comfort decide.
Costs on a resale flat
On a resale purchase you pay stamp duty and registration on the sale document. A June 2026 lender guide gives Mumbai stamp duty as 6 per cent for a male buyer and 5 per cent for a female buyer, and a registration fee capped at ₹30,000 for a property above ₹30,00,000. GST does not arise on the sale of a completed flat. Add the society's transfer charges, legal fees and any brokerage, and ask for each in writing.
Costs on a new flat
In a new project the same stamp duty and registration apply, and GST is added while the flat is under construction. A 2026 tax guide gives 5 per cent for most homes and 1 per cent for affordable homes, on two thirds of the price. Developers also charge for parking, club membership and maintenance deposits. These extras are not part of a government rate, so list them in your agreement and compare the full outgo, not only the headline price.
Paperwork for a resale flat
Ask the seller for the chain of title documents, the previous agreements, the society's share certificate, a no-objection letter from the society and receipts for dues. Check the occupancy certificate and the sanctioned plan. A search of the registers by a lawyer shows past sales and any charge on the flat. Confirm that the area on the papers matches the area on site. Missing links in the chain of title are a warning to pause and ask.
Paperwork for a new flat
For a new project, start with the MahaRERA registration number and read the project page. Check the developer's title documents, approvals and the draft agreement for sale. The Act limits the advance to ten per cent of the cost before a registered agreement. Compare the carpet area in the agreement with the sanctioned plan. Ask for the payment schedule, the possession date and the interest the developer owes you for delay. Keep every receipt.
Risk in each choice
The main risk on a resale flat is title or unpaid dues, and these are found by checking papers before you pay. The main risk in a new project is delay or a stalled build. The Act lets you claim a refund with interest, or interest for every month of delay, if possession is late. It also makes the developer fix defects reported within five years of possession. These remedies reduce risk but do not remove it.
How the loan works for each
For a resale flat, the lender usually pays the seller against the registered documents after its lawyer clears the title. For a new flat, the lender pays the developer in stages that follow the payment schedule and the construction progress, and you pay interest on the amount released. The lender asks about the project's approvals in both cases. Ask each lender how it handles a resale flat that still carries the seller's existing loan.
Tax at the time of purchase
If you buy a resale flat from a resident seller for more than ₹50,00,000, a 2026 tax guide says the buyer deducts 1 per cent tax at source on the price or the stamp duty value, whichever is higher. The buyer deposits that amount with the tax office and the seller gets credit for it. A new flat bought from a developer follows a different path. Section numbers may change under the Income-tax Act 2025, so confirm them.
What to inspect in person
In a resale flat, check seepage, plumbing, electrical wiring and the state of the common areas. Ask about water supply and any repair work planned by the society. In a new project, visit the site, compare the sample flat with the specifications in the agreement and read the project page's progress update every quarter. Take a surveyor or an engineer along. Photographs and dated notes support you if a dispute arises.
Check before you rely on this
Stamp duty, GST, registration, tax deducted at source and loan limits all change. The state publishes stamp duty and ready reckoner rates at igrmaharashtra.gov.in, GST notifications are at cbic-gst.gov.in, and the Income Tax Department lists current deduction rules at incometax.gov.in. Project registration is listed on the MahaRERA site. Confirm every figure at these sources before you pay, and have a lawyer read your agreement.